At the other end of this year we were ranting about
the death of the album, and the significance of the studio album as a band's definitive statement of art and intent in time and space at that particular moment of their journey (thanks very much John Mitchell, sorry about that whole
getting-stabbed thing). Albums are a time capsule of a band's environment, influences and development which cherry-picking tracks off iTunes is never going to reflect to the same rich depth. And there's plenty of bands who've never managed to get their shit together to lay down that one coherent statement, despite writing great music and in many cases being great live acts - Hunters and Collectors, Black Sabbath, Foo Fighters and the Black Crowes are arguably all examples of bands whose potential never really validated into a great single album you can wave at hipsters as evidence music was never as good as it was long long before they bought their first pair of oversized white-rimmed sunnies.
So to that end the venerable
Beeso and I set each other a challenge - list our top 50 studio albums of all time, with the following provisos:
(1) No compilation albums - fairly self-explanatory
(2) No live albums - quite a bit of to-and-fro on this, but in the end a live album has a stand-out advantage vs a studio album in that it's inherently a compilation of sorts (f'rinstance it'd be easy to argue there's three or four Led Zep live collections which are better albums than their best studio effort, simply because of greater depth of material available). In the end we've added an additional top 10 of live albums to follow on from the main list
(3) Only one album per artist - otherwise Beeso would have put Def Leppard's back catalogue 1 through 10, obviously
(4) Only pick from albums you own - not really a hard and fast rule but it's hard to argue an album is in your top 50 if you haven't ever actually shelled out to buy it for yourself.
OK then. My entirely subjective, intentionally argumentative, mostly wrong take on the
Top 50 Studio Albums Of All Time starts nnnnnnow...
50. Jet - Shine On (2006)
As mentioned previously (back when we reviewed it as a newbie) this is a more coherent album than The One With All The Hits On It.
49. Filter - Title Of Record (1999)48. Deja Voodoo - Brown Sabbath (2004)
You won't have heard of this, but it's possibly the first and greatest ever 'beer drinking concept album' (as described by its creators, Matt and Chris from awesomely awful NZ TV show
Back of The Y)
47. Audioslave - Revelations (2006)46. Hoodoo Gurus - Crank (1994)45. Foo Fighters - There Is Nothing Left To Lose (1999)One of those bands you wish made better studio albums. Awesome live.
44. Veruca Salt - Eight Arms To Hold You (1997)43. Metallica - Metallica (1991)Had to be here, by law.
42. The Cult - Sonic Temple (1989)41. Red Hot Chili Peppers - Blood Sugar Sex Magik (1991)A good example of the album as a statement in time and space. The same dudes tried to reform and record the same album a bunch of times since in the late '90s and '00s, and failed.
40. The White Stripes - Elephant (2003)39. Judas Priest - British Steel (1980)38. The Hives - Veni Vidi Vicious (2000)
Most of which ended up in the more broadly familiar
Your New Favourite Band (2001) - disqualified as technically it's a greatest hits compilation.
37. Guns 'N' Roses - Appetite For Destruction (1987)Again - had to be here.
36. The Fratellis - Costello Music (2006)35. Pearl Jam - Vs. (1993)34. TISM - Machiavelli And The Four Seasons (1995)Random factoid: this was the first actual CD I ever bought.
33. Them Crooked Vultures - Them Crooked Vultures (2009)32. Nirvana - Nevermind (1991)31. Spinal Tap - This Is Spinal Tap (1984)
Technically this is a soundtrack, but it's not a compilation - actually a studio album from one (very talented) group of musicians, the actors/writers behind Spinal Tap themselves.
30. Regurgitator - Unit (1997)
This was very, very close to being their Band In A Bubble album
Mish Mash (2004), a remarkable effort considering how it was written and recorded, and an extreme example of that idea of a studio album being a statement by a band at a defined time and of a defined place (both physically and artistically.)
29. The Presidents of the United States of America - The Presidents of the United States of America (1995)28. Spiderbait - Tonight Alright (2004)27. Even - A Different High (2001)26. Blues Explosion - Damage (2004)25. Grinspoon - Easy (1999)24. Powderfinger - Vulture Street (2003)Take this out of their catalogue and they're a singles band who never released a decent album.
23. Rage Against The Machine - Rage Against The Machine (1992)Back into '92. Still in a room without a view.
22. Airbourne - Runnin' Wild (2007)
Yeah, it's a '70s pub rock pastiche. But it's a bloody good one.
21. You Am I - Convicts (2007) – not any of the great albums of the 90s?Maybe a bit of a surprise not to have any of the great Triple J albums of the early '90s - the ARIA number 1s like
Hi Fi Way and
#4 Record - but as a statement by an angry, discarded, melancholic rock frontman,
Convicts is the most coherently argued album in YAI's catalogue.
20. The Stooges - Raw Power (1973)Christing bollocks, they didn't misname this one. Still holds the record for the loudest-mixed album in the world.
19. The D4 - 6Twenty (2001)Almost missed the start of Bathurst 2002 in order to head into Brisbane city on the Sunday morning after Livid to get this sucker (since the rest of Brisbane is shut on Sundays, thanks v. much Ghost of Joh.) That's dedication homes.
18. Frenzal Rhomb - A Man's Not A Camel (1999)Though 1997's
Meet The Family is also pretty good.
17. The Black Keys - Thickfreakness (2003)16. Wolfmother - Wolfmother (2006)Yeah, it's a '70s Zep-Purple-Sabbath pastiche. But it's a bloody good one.
15. Cream - Disraeli Gears (1967)14. Electric Six - Fire (2003)13. Reef - Glow (1997)Sight unseen, this may be the only album which is common between this list and Beeso's.
12. Shihad - The General Electric (1999)
The 'Had have been touring this one as a whole album played live. That would be awesome.
11. The Donnas - Spend The Night (2002)Allison Robertson is still teh hotness. As the great Flange Gasket put it in their unreleased demo
Sandra Sultry: 'Getting on a bit it's true, but Christ I would, and so would you'
10. Led Zeppelin - Physical Graffiti (1975)Double album. Shades
I, II, Random Runes et al on sheer force of content.
9. Deep Purple - Machine Head (1972)
One of the few places you'll find Purple beating Zep in the Battle of the Great '70s British Heavy Metal Inventorers. But deservedly so.
8. The Monarchs - Make Yer Own Fun (2001)Why Brad Shepherd was the greatest Guru of them all. Sorry, Dave Faulkner.
7. Oasis - Definitely Maybe (1994)>>>>>>> that fucking annoying
Morning Glory album that chicks liked.
6. The Stalkers - Rock N' Roll (2002)You could argue this is actually an EP, being only seven tracks. But JESUS what a seven tracks. Seriously high-octane garage punk supergroup.
5. The Jimi Hendrix Experience - Are You Experienced? (1967)The man's a fricken genius. The new release
Valleys Of Neptune is also brilliant, transcends the whole obvious-cash-in context behind it.
4. The Datsuns - The Datsuns (2002)
This album grew on me. It began as a'ight, but not as listenable as some of the other 'new rock' acts of the same era. Nearly eight years later, as an album, it stands above the lot of them.
3. The Sex Pistols - Never Mind The Bollocks, Here's The Sex Pistols (1977)THE greatest punk album. In THE history. Of THE world.
2. Motorhead - Ace Of Spades (1980)The only card you need. Roight.
1. AC/DC - Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap (1976)Why not Back In Black? Or T.N.T.? Truth is, AC/DC made the same studio album 20 times - as they said themselves - it's just that one album happened to be one of the greatest albums every recorded. This is as much an award for the other great versions of that one album as
Dirty Deeds, but the latter shades it for having (a) Bon (b)
Jailbreak (c) Three or four songs written in 12 bar bloooze style (d) Bon (e)
Big Balls (f) Bon and (g) The immortal line 'Get your fuckin jumbo jet orf my airport' delivered by (h) Bon.
You will notice, no Def Leppard. Unless you're quite unwell (*cough AJ cough*) you will understand it too.
Bonus Easter Egg - the
top ten live albums of recorded history:
10. Rage Against The Machine - Live At The Grand Olympic Auditorium (2000)
If you're going to fuck off, fuck off with a great statement. This was theirs.
9. Black Sabbath - Reunion (1997) Back when they got together the first time, and everyone still had their own teeth. Huge sound.
8. You Am I - The Convict Stain (2007, recorded 2003 LatW)This was a Triple J Live at the Wireless show from 2003, when You Am I had just been dumped by Sony-BMG in favour of taking on more Idol rejects. A whole bunch of their mates from bands like Tex Perkins, Kram, Adelita, Burnt Fanny from the Finger, Kev from the Jebs and even fucking NFa from Datsun 1200 Techniques chimed in to Add Value, and it contained Much Awesome.
7. Led Zeppelin - How The West Was Won (2004, recorded 1973)Triple album. Content wins. Plus this has a version of The Ocean so chumpy you can caaaarve it. Much hugerer than the anaemic studio version (separate argument -
Houses Of The Holy, worst Zep studio album ever? Even worse than
In Through The Out Door? Discuss.)
6. Frenzal Rhomb - Mongrel (1998)You'll never have heard of this nor seen it, probably - was an add-on to the deluxe version of Meet The Family - but it captures absolutely what Frenzal were as a live act. Loud, sharp, acerbic and funny as fuck.5. Hoodoo Gurus - Doppelganger (1998)
An awesome collection of cuts from Triple J Live At The Wireless sessions throughout the '80s and '90s, mostly covers and rareties.
4. The Jimi Hendrix Experience - BBC Sessions (1998, recorded 1967-69)The whole BBC Sessions series (technical controversy, compilations or live albums? Have decided on the latter) are brilliant - the Led Zep one's particularly good - but this is the best.
3. Shihad - Pacifier Live (2003)Don't get a Kiwi metal band angry. America did, by making them change their name, then ignoring them. This has just about the fucking hugest sound ever laid to tape.
2. Jimmy Page and the Black Crowes - Live At The Greek (1999)Better than any of the Led Zep live albums? Yessir. This was very, very good.
1. AC/DC - Live (1991) - heaps of great live albumsAs with their studio output, AC/DC live albums are many and plentiful, and most of them are awesome.
If You Want Blood and
Let There Be Rock - The Movie (Live In Paris) were both excellent late 70s efforts. But
Live (1991) gets it for THAT guitar sound. And for turning me into an AC/DC fan in the first place.
Right, that's my lot. I'm not sure I agree with me, but drop me a line to discuss your point of view and I would be happy to explain why you're hopelessly, unutterably wrong.
The Doctor is OUT.