It may surprise you further to know that there are some individuals who, rather than talking bollocks on a voluntary basis, actually get paid to do so. Professional bullshit artists, perhaps, though that would mean mixing one's scatological metaphors (although still along bull-related lines) and that would never do. These people are called commentators. Some of them are very good at what they do. Most of them are untrammelled dog flange. In order to dissociate those that are The Shit from those that are simply Shit, we present Cash for Comment: the legends, the motormouths and the irrevocable fucktards of the com-box.
These folks are The Shit:
10. Neil Crompton, motorsport, Seven Network/Ten Network/Seven Network again In his day Cromley was a handy race driver - a couple of Bathurst podiums for various decent teams attest to that. (He actually started in the mid '80s for Brock's Holden squad and Funnily enough if he'd been able to get his international race licence in time for Bathurst '87 he would have ended up in the car which Brock took over to win the race after the Euro Ford Sierras were disqualified.) Anyway Crompton was useful but not a lot more, but he's been at the commentary gig for as long as he's been driving the things - instead of driving in that '87 Bathurst he was reporting from pitlane for Seven - and is one of those in the current Seven V8 Supercar combox who clearly knows their shit. As distinct from the rest of them who clearly know they're shit.
9. Rabs, league and swimming, Nine Network (and before that Ten, but we won't mention that now)
Call it a token of our appreciation, just for having to deal with Fatty, fucking Phil Gould, and now Laurie Daley, best known for flogging himself witless in the change rooms after Canberra's first NSWRL grand final win while PM Hawke and NSW Premier Greiner were being introduced to the victorious side. At least he's got Sterlo to offer some sort of vaguely sensible contributions (though if he says 'If we freeze play there' one more time he's getting that tellustrator up the shnozz).
8. Fox Sports rugby (the A team - Greg Clark, Phil Kearns, Greg Martin)
Buddha Handy used to live over the road from our place. He was fat and hideous and so was his son. Anyway he's long since been pensioned off and the Fox Sports combox now features the abovementioned bunch of good bastards, all of whom are head, shoulders, knees and toes above the dour, dreary, chippy lot of fuckers who Sky Sports NZ employ to commentate on their deadly-bloody-serious rugby coverage (other than Murray Mexted, who usually can be relied upon to say something completely inappropriate about any random hottie which the Sky camera monkeys can locate in the crowd while bored during halftime). Australian Super 14 broadcasts are entertaining. NZ ones aren't. Symptomatic of a country which seriously needs to get the fuck over itself with reference to union, backed up by the fact an independent auditor was called in to review the AB's quarter-final exit in the World Cup, whose report was made public today (just the six months or so after the game.) The equivalent Wallaby report would have been published within 15 minutes and would have read something like: The story of the Wallabies at World Cup 2007: They sucked. The End.
Anyway, more power to the Fox team; anyone who can make even Reds games fun to watch have to be worth the monthly subscription.
7. Sky Sports NZ cricket (Martin Crowe, Mark Richardson, Simon Doull, Ian Smith et al) What the Kiwis DO do well is cricket commentary, with a tribe of irreverant, knowledgeable, opinionated ex-players who unlike their fawning Strayan counterparts in the Nine combox (particularly the late arrivers - Tubs, Slats and Heals, I'm looking at you) aren't afraid to dispatch rockets up various underperforming local 'heroes' as and when the situation merits it. Yet despite being willing, unlike Nine or their own network's rugby coverage, to set national propaganda aside and point out how arse their own troops are on occasion, they're still a funny bunch of bastards who resolutely decline to take themselves too seriously.
6. Keith Huewen and Julian Ryder, world superbikes of the late Nineties and early Naughties, WSBK international feed
Good commentators need to have at least two critical bases covered in order to do their job properly: they need to be factually correct, and they need to be impartial. Keef and Julian were neither, particularly when FOGGGGYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!! (aka multiple world superbike champion Carl Fogarty) was going around - he was a Brit and so were they. But unlike some of those on the Other List below, Keef and Julian get a pass on this for being highly amusing cunts. They were also helped by presiding over probably the most dynamic era of motorbike racing, the World Supers of the late 90s. While MotoGP (then known as 500cc GP) was languishing in post-Doohan, pre-Rossi dullness, World Supers were going through their golden era (not counting their current golden era) of works bikes for Africa, elbow-to-elbow racing and last-lap dices every second race, and Keef and Julian were well amongst it. I think they do the domestic BBC British superbike coverage these days, while we get the shouty Jonathan Green (a converted football commentator) and Steve Martin, freshly-retired Aussie world superbiker and remarkably perceptive rookie pundit.
5. Martin Tyler, football, Sky Sports UK and occasionally SBS Speaking of football... which we weren't, but anyway.... Martin Tyler IS international football in Australia. His dulcet tones have illuminated most of the last twenty years' world cups and Euro championships (on top of countless other international fixtures, Champions League and English Premiership games) and without exception each game he's called has benefited from his contribution. The Richie Benaud of football commentary.
4. Richie Benaud, cricket, Nine Network/BBC The Richie Benaud of cricket commentary. An absolute, unalloyed, Teflon-coated, cast-iron, armour-plated legend. When he goes, the legend of the Nine commentary team (as lionised by Billy Birmingham) will go with him. Nine are just hoping like the Jesus fuck that he's not going particularly soon. ('Jesus fuck', in case you were wondering, was Mary Magdalene's job description.)
3. Barry Sheene, MotoGP, Nine and Ten Networks 1987-2003
From one who will inevitably leave us one day to one who sadly already has. From the early days with 'Huuuuuugggge' Darrell Eastlake on Nine, calling Gardner and Doohan doing battle with Rainey, Lawson and Schwantz, 1976/77 world champ Sheene is THE reason that I ended up loving bike racing as much as I do. 'E was the morster of goin' forster, know wot I mean? And thanks to Bazza, allegedly useful Spanish bike-pedaller Carlos Checa is still to this day known as 'Charlie Chuckit'. Even if his punishing overuse of the phrase 'consistently inconsistent' made you want to grind off his other pinkie.
2. Les Murray and Johnny Warren, football, SBS and noone else thanks very much For Bazza and bikes, read Laszlo Urge, Captain Socceroo, the fine institution of the Special Broadcasting Service, and football. We didn't get SBS in the sticks until around '95 (about the same time we got Triple J) but even before then the legend of Les and Johnny had made it as far as the Clarence. I'll always remember the sight of Johnny Warren breaking down in tears at the end of the MCG Iran World Cup qualifier in 1997, when we were 20 minutes away from France 98, and still managed to fall short. Fucking El Tel. Captain Socceroo never lived to see us make a World Cup, but he was remembered the night we did; cue SBS pundit Craig Foster's cry after Aloisi's penalty, not of GOAL!!! or ALOISI!!!! or even HERE WE COME GERMANY YOU LOT OF STEIN WIELDING LEDERHOSEN FREAKS!!! but of... JOHNNY WARREN!!! Oddly fitting, really.
1. Roy Slaven and HG Nelson, pretty much everything (but particularly The Greatest Game Of All), Triple J and occasionally the Seven Network at Olympics time And now let's welcome the team that can open the batting and take the new ball up the hill into the wind. Who can turn defence into attack in a twinkling of an eye. Who've enjoyed the highs and learned from the lows. Who are all the better for recent racing and in the wash-up at the end of the day win a lot more than they lose...
Roy and HG are not only brilliant satirists, after more than 20 years calling games they're also brilliant commentators. They fucking rule. The End.
Highly commended:
Dennis Cometti, AFL, Seven I'm with Fitzy on this - he'd be a reason to watch AFL, if AFL was in any way watchable.
John McEnroe, tennis, various networks Calls it as he sees it. A fairly unattractive character quality as a player, but illuminating as a commentator.
Tiffany Cherry, sports news, ESPN
For no other reason other than she's managed to parlay a career in serious sports journalism despite having a name more befitting of a Californian porn starlet.
At least it gives her some alternative employment options going forward.
...Whereas these folks are simply Shit:
5. The Moose, league, mostly Ten
...a.k.a. Thesaurus Rex Mossop, dual international, Manly stooge, bigot, homophobe and tautologist extraordinaire. The Moose's commentary confabulations were so prominent that Australian playwright Alex Buzo used to publish annual awards surrounding his mullering of the English language. Aside from being from Manly and for lines such as 'Those two twins look fairly similar, particularly around the head', Rex mainly makes the list for the penultimate characteristic on our initial list, in particular leading an aggressive Christian protest against a Northern Beaches' male nudist beach on the grounds that he refused to have male genitalia 'shoved down his throat'. Odd considering he grew up playing union.
4. Ian Healy, cricket, Nine
Heals is hand-over-fist the worst of the new generation of Strayan cricketer who's made the transition to the central commentary position. While Tubs has his cheerful, hey-everyone-I-used-to-be-captain-and- now-I-flog-Fujitsu-aircons-with-the-Nissan-Cedrics schtick, and Slats can rely on enthusiasm and a not-insubstantial ability to actually commentate on cricket games, Heals has nuthin'. Other than jingoistic parochialism and some very half-arsed ideas, usually shut the fuck down very swiftly by Richie, Chappelli et al. Just like in the grown-up Australian team, this is another representative cricket side in which he's probably going to be replaced by Adam Gilchrist - and this time there won't be boos ringing around the 'Gabba when it happens.
3. Pretty much any golf commentator, golf, television
Golf is gay. OK, playing it's all right, hitting several shades of Christ out of a small white object can't help but be cathartic, but watching it on TV? And getting paid to talk about it? OK, so that pair of Poms who Seven drag out every year to accompany Jack 'Position A, Sandy' Newton are listenable, and Radar Riley is engagingly drunk the entire time he's on course, but everyone else - fuck off. Particularly Johnny Miller. And Faldo, you dreary old fart. You were duller than a wet Tuesday in Invercargill throughout your career, you're not John McEnroe, don't pretend to be interesting now.
2. Paul 'Fatty' Vautin, league, Nine
...Actually fuck it, half the Nine league commentary team are shit. Brandy Alexander and Warren Smith are better on Fox, they're actually better for having offloaded 'Tugga' Daley onto Nine. But Fatty and Gould... Jesus suffering fuck. (Mary Magdalene had a headache that day.)
1. James Allen, Formula One, ITV and the universal F1-TV English language feed
James Allen is unequivocably the worst commentator to draw a salary for talking about sport on television anywhere in the world. He is the mother and father of all shit commentators. As discussed earlier, to be a decent commentator you need at the very fucking least to be (a) factually correct (usually would do), and (b) vaguely impartial. Allen is neither. He is both constantly, unutterably, amateuristically WRONG about some of the dumbest shit you can imagine a long-term F1 journo-broadcaster to be, and he is about as unbiased as a lawn bowl, particularly now that Hamiltron 1.0, The Ultimate Driving Machine, has been loosed upon the world. Enough has been said by this and more esteemed sites (such as Sniff Petrol's Stop The Cock campaign) about just how face-clawingly shit James Allen is at commentating about car racing, or breathing, or anything, but perhaps his greatest offence is this: His festering Little Englander hideousness, newly evoked in the wake of Hamiltronmania, has even started to infect his previously excellent colleague at ITV, former F1 pilot Martin Brundle, to the point where Brundle publically (and without any evidence whatsoever) accused Nando Alonso of having 'brake tested' Hamiltron in the recent Bahrain GP - that is to claim Nando stuffed his brakes on in a straight line so that Hamiltron would pile into the back of him. Why, exactly, would anyone do something so fucking stupid, let alone a double world champion who could probably figure out F1 cars work best when they haven't been run into by other F1 cars? Yet this 'brake test' line was repeated and perpetuated by The Cock along with the whole ITV commentary clusterfuck, a shower of 'tards with the mentality of Fleet Street and the IQ of an ant colony, even though any bastard could tell Hamiltron had simply fucked up a couple lines of code and ploughed straight up the Russell Coight of Nando's Renault, which was slower than Willie Mason. As later proven by Renault when they busted out the telemetry from Nando's shitbox, and borne out by Hamiltron when he 'fessed up to fucking up. And yet no apology yet from Allen, Brundle and ITV for slandering the dude on international television...
But chin up all you Cock haters (no, not you butch lesbian types), there may be light on the horizon - the BBC have outbid ITV for the rights to F1 from next season onwards (after ITV trumped the Beeb for Champions League rights) and there's a decent chance the existing ITV commentary team won't move across with the rights.So here's to international English-language F1 coverage with something different: a refreshing lack of Cock.
The Doctor is OUT.








